People often ask for advice on how to follow one faith while their family is another. Some of it is about how to get along with everyone and not piss anyone off. Others are more dramatically silly, like "As a Wiccan, am I allowed to attend a Church service?" (No, you'll burst into flame upon entering...seriously, what are you expecting me to say to that?)
There's a difference between participating and believing. I see no reason why my gods would take offense at me entering a church, particularly since I also don't see them taking offense at me at making offerings to other polytheistic gods. I go to church for weddings and funerals, because those are primarily about the bridal party and the deceased, and I'm certainly not going to slight them over their choice of religion.
I don't repeat prayers in church. I stand or sit quietly while such things are going on. I don't believe what those prayers are saying, so I do not say them, but I also don't make a show of not saying them, because I'm a guest in their house.
But I was faced with a new scenario this week. If you follow me on about.com, you probably know that my 62 year old mother had a stroke in May and I've spent a good portion of the summer helping with her. Mom has always said grace every day before every evening meal. Mom's communication centers have been damaged now. Still, for the first few meals at home, she was able to say some form of grace. But one night she just couldn't find the words, and it was clearly heartbreaking.
So I said it. I hailed that God is great and thanked him for our meal. I used the prayer I had memorized by rote as a child. I prayed to a God in which I don't believe.
And I'm OK with that. Because it wasn't about my beliefs at that moment. It was about my mom's welfare and family tradition and holding onto what little normalcy the family has at the moment. My only real concern was if Mom would suddenly feel like I've been put on the spot to act outside my religion and, thus, feel guilty.
I don't have to pout and stomp my feet and declare it an affront to my Wiccaness. The fact is my family IS Christian and it has Christian traditions. Yet I have been Wiccan for 20 years within that family with very little friction, and almost all of that friction came from the first few years when I was still an awkward and somewhat rebellious teen or college student.
There's a difference between practicing and believing. My gods know my beliefs.
Practicing doesn't make you a believer. Saying a Christian prayer doesn't make you a Christian. Likewise, reciting a Wiccan ritual or collecting Wiccan tools doesn't make you a Wiccan. Do you understand? Do you believe? Do you have a purpose for the ritual you work or the item you use? Because if you can't answer "yes," then you are looking like a Wiccan, not actually being a Wiccan.
Wicca by the Book
11/01/2009 11:57:00 PM | beginner tips, rant, She's not with me..., Wicca | 3 comments »I've been hanging out on Yahoo!Answers for a few years now answering questions. In the beginning, I answered practically every question I came across about Wicca. Over time, however, I've grown decidedly jaded. I understand that there are a lot of misinformed and uninformed people out there, and in some cases I appreciate them seeking answers, but there's a lot of stuff that just make me want to bang my head into my desk.
One of my biggest pet peeves is the number of questions about how to do rituals "correctly." I'm not talking esoteric meanings here. I'm talking about "I want to do a ritual for Samhain but I only have blue candles. Will it still work with blue candles?" I have to restrain myself from replying somewhere along the lines of "Well, you could, but the temporal energies are likely to backfire, obliterating your coven," or "No, the Goddess abhors blue in October. She thinks it makes her look fat."
These questions come from a mentality that is, to me, quite contrary to Wicca and bred by our fast-food society: I want spirituality. Publish a quick guide with easy to follow step for me to gain understanding of the universe. Please avoid big words. Thanks.
if people who ask these questions would sit back and think for even a minute about what they are actually asking, it should sound ludicrous. Can you imagine someone asking if a Catholic Mass would still "work" if they changed the colors of the candles?
We have all of these marketers emphasizing crystal wands and fancy athames and blessed candles, and newcomers fall hook line and sinker for them. Heaven forbid our faith require thought and patience and energy and trial-and-error. That would be practically unAmerican.
Q of the Day: Alternatives to Visualizing
3/31/2009 12:29:00 AM | beginner tips, Question of the day, Wicca | 1 comments »A lot of the books I have talk about visualising various things (white light, pentacles, etc etc). I can't do this. I don't think in pictures, I think in words. If I try and visualise "white light" all I think is "white light" in my head. Does this mean I can't be a Wiccan? Is there an alternative to visualising?
Not being able to visualize certainly does not mean you cannot be Wiccan. Visualization is a tool that Wiccans regularly use, but to say that non-visualizers can't be Wiccan would be like saying someone without an athame can't be Wiccan.
Magic happens within us. Visualization helps us focus on the task at hand. It's the frame of mind the white light puts you in that's important, not the image of white light itself.
Since I myself am very visually oriented, I'm not sure what to suggest. Perhaps there are sounds that you may associate with your practices that would help you, so that you "visualize" sound instead of images. For example, if you're trying to consecrate something, you might think of a clear bell ring or the rush of wind rather than white light.
How you go about that will be a lot of trial and error, but Wicca has a lot of trial and error in it, even for us visual people. What Wicca teaches are practices that people tend to find useful. Not everyone finds every practice helpful. People start to adjust things so as to best suit their own mindset.
Q of the Day: Practice Before Dedication
3/26/2009 11:39:00 AM | beginner tips, Question of the day, Wicca | 0 comments »I understand and support why you and many others recommend waiting to dedicate yourself for several years until you are confident this is the path for you. However...I do feel led to pray to both my God and the Elements for guidance and such. I don't feel wrong in doing this, but I almost feel like I'm going against what is "accepted" by not waiting to do this until I've declared myself. I'm curious as to what's your opinion on this?
My first thought here is don't ever do something merely because it isn't "accepted." That's falling into the trap of groupthink, and is really detrimental to your own personal spirituality. Look at the reasons why something is or isn't accepted and then judge whether those reasons make sense. If they don't, then my general thought is you should do what seems best for you. Maybe that means the term "Wicca" doesn't really accurately describe you (depending how much you deviate from "accepted" definitions), but that's no reason to not follow your heart on spiritual matters!
As far as the specifics here: many solitary Wiccans mark their formal entrance into Wicca with a dedication ritual, and we generally recommend a minimum year and a day of study before you do that so that you can make a truly informed decision. That doesn't mean we ask for credidentials. We're not going to question you on how long you studied or whether you dedicated yourself, and honestly, our opinion of you isn't going to change if you tell us you have or have not done a dedication ritual.
Second, just because you haven't formally committed yourself to this path doesn't mean you can't practice anything religious-looking. Wiccan study isn't just about reading. It's about experiencing. So if you feel comfortable with ritual, try ritual. If you want to speak with your gods, by all means speak with your gods! You certainly don't need an official religion to speak with the gods; I know several people who have no religion, yet describe themselves as having a "personal relationship with God." What goes on between you and them is between you and them.
In today's scientific world, there is a habit of commonly designating anything not reinforced by science as "superstition." Because neopagans commonly accept that the world can be manipulated through "magic," which in turn is also commonly called superstitious by wider Western culture, neopagans tend toward the notion that labelling anything as superstition is wrong.
The fact is just because we hold a minority opinion does not mean we should stop thinking critically. Just because we respect some ancient beliefs does not force us to accept all ancient beliefs as valid.
We all structure ritual differently. Some of us work on elemental models, some use tables of correspondences (with various logic systems behind those tables), some work with few accouterments, etc. We all find different things that work...and different things that do not work.
When you incorporate an item into ritual for no better reason than some book says you should, that's superstition. Minimally, you should understand why the source is suggesting such a use and then make a judgement on that reasoning.
This issue recently came up for me in a discussion on the use of herbs. Personally, I'm not a big fan of herbs. I often use a pleasing incense, but the choice of scent is almost entirely personal preference, not supposed mystical properties.
In my experience, the different meaning associated with plants varies wildly from source to source, and the majority do not even indicate what logic they base their suggestions on. For all I know, they've developed their list through use of a magic 8-ball. Even if the writer is working from older sources, they're all using different folklore, different cultures, etc. These older sources are working on the idea that plants have inherent magical properties, in part because they didn't differentiate between magical and mundane properties. I accept that many plants of mundane properties, which can be tested. But when every source is saying something different about a claim that cannot be verified, I am left with the conclusion that we are dealing with superstition rather than an accurate understanding.
The ancients didn't actually have all the answers. While they certainly should not be discounted just because they are from a time long ago, they likewise should not be accepted solely because they are from a long time ago. That is counter to reason.
Question of the Day: Using Published Spells
12/04/2008 07:31:00 PM | beginner tips, Question of the day, Wicca[My friend gave me] To Light a Sacred Flame by Silver RavenWolf. I haven't really started reading the book at all, just kind of skimmed through and looked a little at the spells. But after reading your post on why most wiccans despise Silver RavenWolf I decided that I'm not going to read the book. What I was wondering is are the spells in the book completely worthless or I guess wrong in a way? I know you write your own spells and do what feels best to you but since I'm starting out I kind of like using the spells I find in books as my 'guide' but I don't want to use RavenWolfs' if she really is that bad.
Let's clarify something first: spells are not effective simply because they contain the "correct" ingredients or chants. The suggestion that magic works like a recipe is one of the reasons why so many people want to tear their hair out upon reading Ravenwolf's works (among others).
Magic is something that works within you. The tools, stones, chants, gestures and everything else are there to help your focus. They can all contribute to the effectiveness of your working, but only if you understand how they relate to each other. A simple spells will a few but understood props is far more effective than one with piles of props if you don't understand why you're using them.
Because symbolic understanding is personal, many people write their own spells. However, if you're uncomfortable with that, your hesitation will only hinder you. on the other hand, if someone else's spell makes sense to you, then it makes perfect sense to use it.
Will you personally find meaningful stuff in Ravenwolf's work? Only you can answer that.
If there is only one piece of advice I can give to religious seekers, it would be this: never stop asking yourself why you do what you and believe what you believe. Why do I cast a circle? Why do I face the four cardinal points when I do so? Why does my altar face east? (Or north, or whatever.)
Any ritual without purpose is pointless. Oftentimes we don't even realize we're trivializing a ritual. We study and practice and everything seems to be fitting together well, so it must be "right," right?
The question of "why?" has brought me up short before. I know why I follow the gods that I do, and why I generally practice the way I practice, but there have been times when I have tried explaining the purpose of a ritual and suddenly realized that the only reasons I actually have is because someone I respect said that's how it should be done.
Realizing you don't have an answer doesn't make you a bad person. It just makes you imperfect, which we all are. More importantly, it offers us an opportunity to be more perfect, to seek out reason for our rituals or altar our behavior according something something that does have meaning.
Identifying our shortcomings is how we progress. It's also how we can avoid merely acting like Wiccans and instead actually be Wiccans.
Question of the Day: Avoiding Fluff
11/04/2008 04:21:00 PM | beginner tips, Question of the day, Wicca | 0 comments »A 16 year old Wiccan seeking fellowship with other intelligent practitioners asked the following:
Can you recommend any *good* books about Wicca (Particularly culture and general philosophy)?
How do I avoid fluff bunnies?
How do I avoid becoming a fluff bunny myself?
How do I get *serious* practitioners to take me seriously?
My book recommendations can be found here: http://wicca.timerift.net/books.shtml . There's very little discussion of Wiccan "culture", which is fine in my book. When people turn Wicca into a culture, it tends to become a fashion statement, which annoys me to no end. Our culture is the community in which each individual lives, and in most cases that's better described as Western (as in Western Civilization), East Coast, West Coast, etc.
Avoiding being a fluff bunny is actually pretty easy: you seek out knowledge rather than sound bites that sound good. If you're worried about being fluffy, you almost assuredly are not. Fluffies don't care.
Avoiding fluffy or simply inaccurate information is much harder, and the fact is we all fall prey to it occasionally. Keep an open mind. If you learn about conflicting claims, examine the evidence for each. Be willing to change your mind when new information becomes available.
When a Wiccan writer is writing about history, take it with a large grain of salt *especially* when he or she doesn't footnote a source for such information. If you find too many problematic statements with a writer, it may be best to discard them entirely. While no one is perfect, multiple errors suggest poor research skills or a flair for writing what will sell rather than what is the truth. You're probably not catching all of the errors in their work - just the most obvious. This is why I warn people away from particularly bad writers like Ravenwolf. Sure, there are some factual statements in her work, but there's no way a beginner can sort between the fact and the fluff. (If you can, you've already advanced past her books).
If anything sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Common sense is important in any religion. There are many Wiccans who actually think they're supposed to check reality at the door because this is a "magical" religion. If you think magic is unrealistic, why on earth are you studying it?
As for being taken seriously, this is going to be very difficult for you for at least the next two years, possibly longer. Most sixteen-year-olds simply aren't serious about it, so it's guilt by association. Also, teaching a minor about religion without parental consent is considered unethical by many of us and can get us in serious legal trouble should your parents make an issue of it. If you're looking for a proper coven, you have to understand that a lot of these groups won't even consider initiation for someone until they are well into their 20s. Those who are younger simply haven't matured enough for the close spiritual work customary in covens.
The only reason people are treated seriously is if they act serious. However, just because you act serious doesn't guarantee you'll be accepted as such. That's the reality of the situation. However, the longer someone knows you and the more they see you behaving maturely and responsibly, the better they are going to view you.
If it makes you feel any better, one of the main reasons I am still a solitary at the age of 34 is because I've never been able to find a group of locals who were both interested in group work and were not fluff bunnies. Being on your own is way better than being in a bad group.
...Only If Your Goddess Is Martha Stewart
11/03/2008 12:10:00 PM | beginner tips, rant, Wicca | 0 comments »Questions about appropriate use of colors, incense, stones and other objects are pretty common from Wiccans today, and it's frustrating because of how focused people have become on stuff, rather than the purpose of said stuff. This weekend I came across a question regarding whether one's altar has to have an altar cloth.
Only if your goddess is Martha Stewart.
Has the commercialization of Wicca has become so acute that some people fear the gods won't listen (or worse, might be retaliatory) if the altar doesn't include a tablecloth? When did our gods become so petty? Why would you want to form a relationship with said gods who have nothing better to do than critique one's design skills? Does anyone think a piece of cloth really confers power to an altar?
An altar is a focus and a reminder of one's relationship with the gods and what task is at hand. Each individual knows how to best accomplish that goal. If an altar cloth (or any other item) adds nothing to the ensemble, then it has no purpose. As you become more involved in Wicca, becoming more comfortable with your own rituals and understanding more about why different Wiccans use different items, you may find that an altar cloth would be a valuable addition. But if you do use one, it should be because it has a purpose, not because you're working off some shopping list.
Out of all of the books on my shelves, only a couple discuss the proper "working tools" of Wicca - nine items considered central to Traditional practice. Many books (and many more websites), however, provide long lists of stuff: candles, bells, brooms, jewelry, stones, altar cloths, cloaks, robes, herbs, amulets, and so on. One commercial Wiccan website I recently encountered even had a category for "bath and beauty." If you find these things useful, so be it. But when these become the center of attention in your practices, the gods lose out to Martha Stewart.
The notion of familiars within Wicca is one of those things that certain people seem to think make them look more Wiccan without the vaguest concept of what a familiar is. Some Wiccans refer to any pet as a familiar. Others use the term for a pet that appears particularly intelligent or seems to have some sort of empathic bond with its owner. That's not what a familiar is. It's a straight up, radical redefinition of a word.
It is true that historical witches were often accused of keeping familiars, and that the familiar in question was often a common household animal such as a cat. These creatures, as they were understood, however, were not pets. They were not even mortal. Familiars were (theoretically) demonic spirits serving the witch. Such entities commonly took the form of a common animal as a disguise and they fed on the blood of the witch.
Are you so sure you want a familiar now?
I understand that people have many different views of exactly what Wicca is. Some of it is misinformation, and some of it is simply differences of well-informed opinions within the community. What I do not understand are the number of people who continue to think that Wicca is for them when they have no grasp at all of it.
"I think I may be Wiccan," is the way some put it, which immediately tells any half-informed listener that the speaker is clueless. I don't mean they've come across bad information. I mean they haven't bothered with any information. I doubt most of these people have picked up a single book on the subject, not even a bad book. One doesn't accidentally follow a religion. You either are or you are not. You either believe, or you don't. You either practice, or you don't.
Of close relation to this type of person is the "I'm a new Wiccan. What am I supposed to do?" I fail to grasp what these people could possibly think Wicca is in even the broadest of terms, if they think they can be a part of it while not even being aware of basic beliefs and practices. Isn't that like saying "I'm a new Christian. Who's this Jesus dude?"
The reasons why certain people see themselves as Wiccan can sometimes be nightmarish: they love the environment, they want spells, they respect other religions, they're psychic, etc. This is all nice. We certainly aren't going to send you away for such outlooks. But how does any of that make you even remotely Wiccan? Seriously, has our education system broken down to such a degree that our children now think that because Wiccans respect the environment, respecting the environment makes one a Wiccan?
Other things that are not distinctly Wiccan and in no way make someone Wiccan:
- Astrology
- Herbalism
- Feminism
- Lesbianism
- Power Crystals
- Ouija boards, seances or other manners of speaking with the dead
- Tarot cards, rune casting or other forms of divination
- Reiki
- Chakras
- Aura reading
One of the common questions I encounter from new Wiccans concerns "rules." What do I need to do as a Wiccan? What am I not allowed to do? What am I required to do?
It's very hard for a lot of people to comprehend that religion does not have to involve absolute rules. That notion comes from Christianity, which heavily influences Westerners' views of religion in general. Christianity has a very concrete goal - salvation - and Christians generally have very solid conditions required for that goal. But not every religion works as Christianity works.
How can you have a coherent religion if no one is following the same rules? Because religion is inherently about belief, not rules. We share general beliefs, but we may approach those beliefs differently. In fact, many of us feel that we should approach each issue individually. Ethics should be determined by the circumstance, not but some impersonal list of rules, for example.
The notion of solid rules in many ways takes away personal responsibility. Followers feel they do not need to consider the ramifications of their actions so long as they technically remain within the rules. They also expect some sort of guarantee of success: if I accomplish X, Y and Z then I will attain goal Q. Wiccan spirituality simply doesn't work like that. Our goals include the gaining of information and understanding and closer communion with our deities. These things do not come out of celestial vending machines just because we insert the correct quarter. They are things to be sought and investigated and examined. To guarantee that a certain ritual will produce an expected effect is like promising that reading Grey's Anatomy (the anatomical guidebook, not the TV show) will make you a doctor.
There's nothing wrong with Wiccan how-to guides in and of themselves. It all depends on exactly what a specific book is attempting to teach. It can be a fine format for teaching the basics of ritual, so long as the steps are being fully explained, rather than simply scripting steps. But if it promises results, or if it keeps the focus on the actions rather than the understanding of those actions, then such materials have missed the mark entirely.
Book Review: Wicca for Beginners
10/13/2008 01:56:00 PM | beginner tips, book reviews, Wicca | 1 comments »
4 out of 5 stars
Thea Sabin, Wicca for Beginners
I'm not sure a book on Wicca has ever been given a more appropriate title. Wicca for Beginners delivers exactly what it promises: truly introductory material for those just beginning to investigate Wicca. It makes no presumptions about what the reader knows, and it doesn't get ahead of itself.
It's meant to be more informative than instructive, which is an approach sorely lacking in available materials today. While there are various basic exercises to assist in understanding, Sabin is far more interested in explaining basic premises and beliefs - the kind of information that will be foundational for Wiccan students as they move on to other books and more complex understandings of Wicca.
Sabin also generally avoids specific ritual. She sometimes gives some examples of phrasings, and she gives some basic outlines for practices, but she steers clear from concrete instructions telling you how many times to turn around or what incense you have to burn. Those details can all come later. Right now a reader needs to understand the bare basics, and this book is superb in delivering it.
By focusing on very rudimentary beliefs, I hope that Sabin's book is also useful for people still trying to figure out if Wicca is for them. If these beliefs simply don't make sense to a reader, that should be taken a very strong hint that Wicca is perhaps not the religion for them. That will certainly spare someone the wasted effort of memorizing a bunch of rituals only to find finally find out that the rituals are based on ideas he or she doesn't agree with or are addressed to beings to whom they have no relationship.
Check out the website for more book reviews.
Question of the Day: Beginner Issues
10/10/2008 10:03:00 PM | beginner tips, Question of the day, Wicca | 1 comments »I have recently began to study Wicca. I have always been interested in it, but just recently started actually researching it. However, I really don't know where to start. I am currently reading Wicca For the Solitary Practitioner by Scott Cunningham and I like it very much. I have some stuff to put on my altar, but does that come later? As far as a God and Goddess, I have always been extremely drawn to ancient Egypt, RA especially. Is anyone accepted as a God and Goddess? After I complete the book, what should my next step be?
Let me start off with some reading suggestions. http://wicca.timerift.net/book_reccomendations.shtml contains a suggested reading list for beginners. It's broken down into topics so you can focus on particular areas as you wish, although I really suggest the first group of books be read first. Many of those books are reviewed on this site and you can order them from Amazon through the site as well. In addition, you can read other reviews here: http://wicca.timerift.net/books.shtml.
Second, I've created a document entitled "How does one Become Wiccan?" at http://wicca.timerift.net/wicca101/become_wiccan.shtml. I think you will find some of your answers in there.
Third, I'll address the specific points you mention. Everything should have a purpose. If an altar means something to you, than use it. If it doesn't mean something, or you feel like you're just shopping off a list for it, then wait until it does mean something and you do have a use for it. One of the biggest dangers I find with eclectics (and I've fallen for it myself) is that they want to do things "right" so they emulate what they read in books even though they really don't have a use for it yet.
There is no approved list of deities in Wicca. Some, I think, work better than others, but the final determination of that has to be you. My suggestion is that if you are finding specific deities calling to you, answer them. Study them. And as you learn more about them and about Wicca, you may discover that deity wasn't actually calling you (personally, Athena has always been one of my favorite deities, but I don't actually have a relationship with her. She's not the one who called me), or you may discover that your choice of deity is right but Wicca may not be the best framework. (I would suggest Kemetic Paganism as an alternative in that case.) Alternatively, you may find that everything works out fine. It's a process of growing and learning.
As for next steps: keep reading, keep practicing, keep learning. Religion is a lifelong endeavor.