Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teaching. Show all posts

More crazy emails from students.  This time it was fairly simple: "Thanks for the F."

No thanks needed.  I didn't give you that F.  You won that F all by yourself.  I merely recognized your accomplishments (or lack of).

Students like to give the impression that poor grades are a reflection of a mean teacher rather than a poor student, but that fact is it is pretty much impossible for dedicated student to fail my class.  Certainly not every earnest student will get an A, but they should pass.  They should even pass relatively well.

But it does require work, and the idea that teachers are big meanies because they expect actual work is a growing concern.  "Your So-Called Education" in the New York Times paint a grim picture of diminishing expectations - and results - in US college education.

So, yes, you should show up regularly, read assigned materials, participate in class, bring required materials, put time and thought into papers, not cheat off the Internet, and study your brains out for exams.  And many students do...and they get good grades, and they actually learn stuff. 

Part of the problem, I think, is that students too often think of college as a source of grades and a diploma rather than as a source for knowledge.  This is particularly the case for classes like mine (history and humanities) which aren't directly applicable to most students' career paths.  You don't need to know who painted the Sistine Chapel in order to be a successful biochemist.  So all students are looking for is a grade.

I am not here to provide a grade.  I am here to teach.  My students will leave my class knowing more than when they went in.  The grade just reflects how well they accomplished garnering new knowledge.

Angry students seem to universally think teachers enjoy failing students.  We don't.  I hate failing students, because it means they didn't learn anything, and I don't like that, even if it's not my fault.  So why do it?  (And I have been asked that)  Accountability.  A good grade is the reward for learning stuff.  Giving a reward for nothing merely continues this cycle of entitlement that certain students suffer, encouraging the notion that hard work really isn't necessary.

Luckily, this opinion isn't universal.  I periodically get compliments from students about how much stuff they learn in my class, or how I made the material accessible and fun so they could more easily learn.  I've repeatedly gotten the comment on my reviews from students that I am "hard but fair" and "tough, but I learned a lot."  I take that to mean I'm doing it right.

I don't believe in the easy A.  If A's are easy, the bar is set far too low.  I state it right on my syllabus: A's represent superior work, not average work.

My favorite teacher in undergrad was also the hardest grader I've ever had.  Even though he taught my specialty (Medieval European history), I sweated bullets in his classes.  An A was never a guarantee.  But I learned tons of information - information that has stayed with me over they years, rather than information that fades five minutes after the exam.  I also could appreciate an A as a real accomplishment, and I learned the value of hard work.

Life expects you to do hard work.  I'm not being overly demanding on this point.

I submitted final grades for my students this week, and already one student is unhappy.  The most amazing email showed up in my inbox:

"I dont understand how a 75% overall on three tests and a paper equal a c/d grade. thought it was a c. I missed ONE class all semester due to weather. The clicker points oviously mean alot to get them right? Good thing I have A's and A/B's in all my other courses. I guess it was a mistake to take this class, escpecially to fill a requirement."
"Clickers" are electronic quiz devices we use.  I put a question up on a PowerPoint and students enter their answers through a small electronic device.

He is right that 75% is a C, but he's ignoring the clicker component of his grade, which is clearly stated on the syllabus as being equally weighted against any single paper or exam.

So, yes, the clickers were important.  And, yes, it was important to get them right.  I'm there to teach them about history, not how to push random buttons on a device.  I know.  I'm demanding.

As for the last sentence, I'm not even sure of the meaning.  Was he expecting the class to be easier because it's a gen. ed. requirement, and most of the students in the class don't really want to be there?  Welcome to adulthood, where you will be expected to do things you don't really like on a regular basis.

I explained to him what the syllabus says about clicker scores, and then suggested that perhaps his real mistake was not taking my class seriously.  Yes, you have to not only show up, but you have to be prepared.  That means opening that great big textbook and investing real time reading the assignments, rather than just cramming the bits that are on exam review sheets.

It means you're a grown-up.  Welcome to the real world.

Student Reviews, Yay!

12/08/2010 03:30:00 PM | | 0 comments »

Every semester, students get to rate me 1 through 10, and they can write comments about me.  I don't get to read them until the beginning of the next semester.

I always face these things with trepidation.  I'm made of pretty stern stuff, and I know that a lot of the negative comments come from students who didn't really apply themselves, but I always resist reading them regardless.

I just looked through last semester's reviews.  Not only did I get some of the highest scores to date, I got a lot of positive comments.  Lots of stuff about how they appreciated my study guides and exam reviews.  Lots and lots of comments about how I know my material (an issue which always makes me nervous, since I cover such a large span of time and can't be an expert in everything).

No mentions of the Black Death being a cover-up for a zombie apocalypse, but I can't have everything.

Really the only complaint I regularly got was that I require a lot of reading.  Welcome to Humanities.  Get over it.  It's a reading-intensive subject.  Nothing I can do about that.

Happy, happy happy dance.