Isaac Bonewits passed in his sleep this morning after a long battle with colon cancer. He was 60 years old. Bonewits was a highly respected member of the neopagan community, where he has been influential for decades...Read more at my Alternative Religions blog.
Isaac Bonewits, Neopagan Pioneer, Dies
8/12/2010 02:24:00 PM | AltReligion CrossPost, paganism, Wicca, witchcraft | 0 comments »The Problem with "Free Spells"
12/21/2009 09:34:00 PM | Question of the day, Wicca, witchcraft | 0 comments »i am new to this whole thing. i registered my email address on spells4free.com requesting for a free weight loss/attractiveness spell in return for signing myself up for their newsletter. is that wrong? the spell is on myself because i am tired of diet products/torturing myself with diets/pills/etc..why are some people born luckily thin and yet others work so hard? is it fair? do you think this spell would still have a future threefold effect or whatever the law of return is in a negative way? should i take back my request?You say you are new to this whole thing. What whole thing? Wicca? Spells? Getting free stuff?
People want to tell themselves they can get something for nothing, but that expectation is completely unnatural. There is no such thing as a free lunch. You only get out what you put in. Reading someone's "spell" does nothing. Not a thing. If you are interested in working magic, you need to understand how it works. Magic comes from the worker, not words on paper.
Life isn't about being "fair." Life is a complex interaction of causes and effects. Each person has things they are better at or worse at. The fact is any goal you seek requires enough effort to overcome existing obstacles. People with slower metabolisms have bigger obstacles than others when in comes to weight maintenance, but in the end it comes down to understanding you body and its needs and having the fortitude to work with it and not give in to cravings.
I can understand why you are frustrated with diet pills, but you seem to just be replacing one quick fix for another. Without active change on your part, you're not going to lose weight. Even dieting is not a permanent fix. Once you lose the desired weight, you have to continue to keep healthy habits or the weight comes back. That's why most fad diets don't work.
Every choice has consequences. That is what the law of return is about. Sometimes the consequence is a simple as "I asked for a spell, and they emailed me one."
As far as attractiveness, that's in the eyes of the beholder. People who are more confident in themselves tend to gain more positive attention. Telling yourself that you need a spell to be worth someone's attention only feeds your lack of confidence.
For a time I lived with a "witch". Not entirely sure if she even had much definition to what kind she believed, or what she drew from, but she made much out of it, even accusing me of persecution. (I simply disagreed, but let it go). Anyhow, as she was moving out, she hung a scissors by a string, pointing down, above the front door, on the inside of the house.
It was hung from a bulletin board tack, which I thought was unsafe, so I took it down. A day later, she put it back up. I took it down again. I found out that it was related to her beliefs, because she left me a nasty note about interfering with her right to practice her religion. I told her that I didn't like the idea of a poorly hung scissors clipping someone in the head, and after I found the scissors up again, I took it down. But this time, I replaced it with a banana. The next day, she had replaced the banana with a Santa Claus christmas ornament, which made me laugh, so I guess good humor won the day.
Anyhow, It's left me honestly curious about it. Do you have any idea what "scissors over the door" means? I'm not aware of anything regarding scissors, although a google search brought up a few links about old superstitions about hanging scissors over a door. It was meant to keep evil influences out of the home. Why your roommate would do this as she was moving out is beyond me, but it sounds like she was crying for attention with all of her leaps of accusations of persecution.Ironically, the scissors as ward-against-evil had strong Christian connotations. The scissors were hung by one loop so they would hang in the open position, like a cross. Also, some websites state that the gesture was supposed to keep "witchcraft" out as well as evil influences!
http://www.catalogs.com/info/gadgets/the-history-of-scissors.html
I think replacing it with a banana was pretty awesome, actually.
Question of the Day: Wiccan History
2/05/2009 02:04:00 PM | history, Question of the day, Wicca, witchcraft | 4 comments »I was reading through your website, especially the 'Myth and History' section, and was wondering if there were any particular books from which you were getting your information. The things I've read directly contradict the things you are saying and I'd like to do as much research as possible to come to the most correct conclusion I can.
I'm going to have to make a guess about the things you are reading, so pardon me if I am incorrect here, although this is the usual scenario in which I see this question.
When looking for expert information, you should go to people who are focused on that specific topic. So when you want to learn about Wicca, going to a Wiccan makes perfect sense...way more sense than one of those books on Wicca written by a conservative Christian, for example. In that same vein, when you're looking for history, you should look toward historians. Just because you've been practicing a religion does not mean you know it's history. This is the case whether you're talking Wicca, Christianity, or something else.
When Wiccan authors talk about history, they generally have little or no familiarity with the materials they claim to be drawing from. A lot of the "witchcraft is ancient religion" comes directly from the works of Margaret Murray. Murray herself was barely familiar with witch-trial records (which is what she claimed to be working from), and the people who quote her generally have no experience at all with such evidence: they just presume it's right because someone published it.
When someone makes a claim about Wicca being ancient, ask yourself how they could possibly even know the facts they are providing. Cavemen left us no writing, yet a variety of Wiccan writers (copying Murray) have stated that witchcraft is the world's oldest religion, dating back 25,000 years. How can we possibly know what people that long ago believed? We can, at best, make some general guesses. If Wicca has been practiced in secret for centuries, how do we know that? No historian has ever pointed out a historical religion that looks anything like Wicca. The usual argument I get is "Well, that's because it was secret." OK, but if it was so secret no historian knows about it, how does some Wiccan author have so much evidence about it? And do they actually offer any evidence, or do they just say "this is how it is"?
If you're interested in Wiccan history, Ronald Hutton's Triumph of the Moon is pretty much required reading. Not only is he a professor of history, he's also an initiated Wiccan. He spends considerable time giving examples of the leaps of logic made by Murray and others and provides numerous opposing pieces of evidence or arguments.
The absurdity of the Murray thesis is discussed in many, many books by historians. Here are some suggestions:
- Baroja, Julio Caro. The World of the Witches, trans. O.N.V. Glendinning. Madrid: Revista de Occidente, 1961; reprint, University of Chicago Press, 1971.(Baroja wrote that claims of pagan cults and Horned Gods are totally in opposition to any and all serious, factual investigation, and he accused the supporters of such claims of using arbitrary archaeological fabrications. He acknowledged, however, that the theory was still highly accredited in the English-speaking world.)
- Burr, G. L. "Review of The Witch-Cult in Western Europe: A Study in Anthropology," The American Historical Review, Vol. 27, No. 4. July, 1922, pp. 780-783. (Burr credits Murray's popularity to "the lack in English of any thorough history of witchcraft." He also states: "To her every confession is true, all the accused guilty, and whether convicted or acquitted. She does not trouble her judgment by hearing even what they say for themselves. Mary Osgood, for example, whose confession she repeatedly quotes, not only retracted it all and was eventually discharged, but handed in (she and her Andover neighbors) a vivid description of the pressure and persuasion by which the confession was extorted.")
- ----------------. "Review of The God of the Witches," The American Historical Review, Vol. 40, No. 3. April, 1935, pp. 491-492.
- Cohn, Norman. Europe's Inner Demons. New York: Basic Books, Inc., 1975.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, Macropaedia Vol. 19. Chicago, London, Toronto, Geneva, Sydney, Tokyo, Manila Seoul, Johannesburg: Helen Hemingway Benton, 1974. (The 1974 edition contains updated info on Witchcraft as well as flat out admitting that it's previous article ont he subject (written by Murray) has been discredited and was, in their words, "highly imaginative.")
- Hutton, Ronald. The Triumph of the Moon: A History of Modern Pagan Witchcraft. Oxford University Press, 1999.
- ----------------. "Paganism and Polemic: The Debate over the Origins of Modern Pagan Witchcraft," Folklore, Vol. 111, No.1. April, 2000, pp. 103-117.
- Loeb, E. M. "Review of The Witch-Cult in Western Europe: A Study in Anthropology," American Anthropologist, New Series, Vol. 24, No. 4. October - December, 1922, pp. 476-478. (Loeb described Murray's approach as "novel," fueled by "a naïve desire for originality combined with an over-facile intuition" resulting in "the most fantastic lack of discrimination in her evaluation of the validity of the court testimony given at the witch trials" and finally "a bewildering mass of false inferences". )
- Larner, Christina. Witchcraft and Religion: The Politics of Popular Belief. Basil Blackwell, 1984. ("We have now reached a stage when it is possible to ignore altogether the once-influential view of Murray.")
- Macfarlane, Alan. "Review of The God of the Witches," Man, Vol. 6, No. 3. September, 1971, p. 506.
- Monter, William. "European Witchcraft: A Moment of Synthesis?" The Historical Journal, Vol. 31, No. 1. March, 1988, pp. 183-185. (Monter lists laying the ghost of Murray to rest as one of the accomplishments of witchcraft historians.)
- Parrinder, Geoffrey. Witchcraft: European and African. 1958; reprint, London: Faber and Faber, 1963.
- Simpson, Jacqueline. "Margaret Murray: Who Believed Her, and Why?" Folklore, Vol. 105, Issue 1/2. 1994, pp. 89-96.
- ----------------. "Scholarship and Margaret Murray: A Response to Donald Frew," Ethnologies, Vol. 22, No. 2. 2000, pp. 1-5 (originally pp. 281-288).
- Thomas, Keith. Religion and the Decline of Magic. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1971. (This book gives the most thorough breakdown of the problems of the Murray thesis that I am familiar with.)
- Wood, Juliette. "Margaret Murray and the Rise of Wicca," The Pomegranate, Vol. 15. Winter, 2001, pp. 45-52.
The scholarship on historical witchcraft, paganism and Wicca can perhaps be best summed up in the following quotes from Hutton and Simpson, both written in response to a non-academic Wiccan named Donald Frew who published an article in 1998 stating the Murray thesis still couldn't be ruled out:
at the opening of the 1970s, the thesis was rapidly revealed as possessing no sustainable basis...More recent research has apparently buried it beyond retrieval, and it must be emphasized how extensive that research has been. Between 1980 and 1995 fifteen international academic conferences were held to discuss the witch trials and their context, and the papers presented there, and generally published in the proceedings, represented only a part of the work carried out in the subject during the past two decades. That united hundreds of scholars, covering between them every European state....None have [sic] found any basis for characterising early modern witchcraft as paganism.
Donald Frew has apparently read not a single one of these works. As a result, his declaration that the hypothesis that witchcraft was a survival of paganism "can't be ruled out" is made without an attempt to engage even with the relevant body of secondary sources, let alone primary records.(Ronald Hutton, "Paganism and Polemic: The Debate over the Origins of Modern Pagan Witchcraft," Folklore, Vol. 111, No.1. April, 2000, p. 110)
Particularly over the past twenty-five years, there have been very numerous books, articles, and conferences in Britain, Europe, and America. Presenting the research of a multitde of scholars, none of whom uncovered any evidence to support her theory, while finding a great deal incompatible with it….Anyone who hopes to reclaim Murray's reputation as a historian, let alone argue that 'the hypothesis that Witchcraft was a survival of paganism…can't yet be ruled out', can only begin to do so by confronting squarely the issues which this huge body of scholarly work has raised. (Jaqueline Simpson, "Scholarship and Margaret Murray: A Response to Donald Frew" Ethnologies, Vol. 22, No. 2 (2000), pp. 4-5.)
Question of the Day: Satanic Witches
1/20/2009 03:53:00 PM | Question of the day, satanists, Wicca, witchcraft | 3 comments »I was just wonder[ing] why you said in you article about RavenWolf, "Satanists have as much claim (if not more) to the term as we do".
The Word "witchcraft" has been around for a very long time, way longer than the religions of Wicca or Satanism. Some Wiccans have adopted the term. That's their prerogative, but it's historically nonsensical. "Witchcraft" has always designated a magical practice, generally a malevolent one, not a religion such as Wicca.
People who practice magic today sometimes term themselves a "witch." Those people can, and do, come from many religions, including both Wicca and Satanism. Since the term is older than us, how can we possibly claim ownership? The term is equally appropriate regardless whether you're referring to a magic-practicing Wiccan or a magic-practicing Satanist. Considering the terms association with malevolent magic, Satanists arguably have the better claim to the word, since they are more likely to work magic against another person.
I'm currently reading Janet Farrar and Gavin Bone's Progressive Witchcraft. A quick flip through in the bookstore looked promising, although so far it's been little more than frustration.
Janet and her late husband Stewart have previously claimed that Wicca was an ancient religion. Since then Janet at least has stated otherwise (Stewart's outlook is unknown to me), and this fact is reiterated in Progressive Witchcraft. Great! The book also admits that magical workers in previous centuries would have never called themselves witches. Fantastic!
But then things start to go sideways. First, the book states that Wicca and witchcraft can be used interchangeably. OK, problematic, although such terminology issues are certainly not new nor are they exactly the biggest problem we face. The real problem comes from repeated mentions of Medieval witchcraft, how witches did things then compared to how witches do things now. There's a couple mentions of ancient witchcraft, and one completely mind blowing claim suggesting that witchcraft has always been the practice of a priesthood (i.e. all members are considered priests).
I'm fuddled not so much by any inaccuracy as by the sheer incomprehensibility of such statements. Wicca is equivalent to witchcraft and Wicca is modern, yet witchcraft is ancient? The basic illogic hurts my brain. And exactly what are we calling historical witchcraft? Continued claims of a priesthood being involved strongly suggest we're still talking about a Murrayesque secret pagan cult even thought the authors appear to be simultaneously distancing themselves from Murray. And if we're discounting Murray, and we admit that the people who were called historically called witches had nothing to do with what we're talking about, why are we continuing to call this...whatever Farrar and Bone are referring to...as witchcraft?
They also denounce the importance Wiccans have previously put on age of practice and lineage, yet they seem to be simultaneously doing literary gymnastics to continue to associate our practices with something ancient. Certainly we borrow bits and pieces from previous cultures, but what we practice is new. We can learn from the past without claiming to be emulating it or descending from it. The continued arbitrary application of the word witchcraft merely confuses readers and frequently perpetuates misinformation.